This post will be relevant for a very short time.
In the famous words of another National Party leader, the current one will be “gone by lunchtime” so these words will be out of date before the clock strikes 12.
Mark down Wednesday August 12, 2026 as the day the National Party took one of the biggest gambles in its 90 year history.
That Christopher Luxon has to go is a no-brainer. He has been an exceptionally uninspiring leader since the beginning of his tenure, infected with corporate word salads and an absence of x-factor. The only question in recent times is whether or not he goes before or after the election.
That he’s survived this long through his various missteps is only due to there being no standout successor.
There still isn’t one now.
The prospect of Erica Stanford becoming Prime Minister is sickening. This is the woman who in her maiden speech said “it will be normal for my children to have their marriages defined by love and not by gender.”
At a lunch I attended where was the guest she was asked, as the then Opposition spokesperson on education, whether or not she would put a stop to the transgender promoters Inside Out having access to the country’s classrooms. She said she wouldn’t. And now as the Minister she hasn’t.
There is TV news coverage of her and her closest rival for the top job Chris Bishop in “costume” walking in the Pride Parade.
She has said publicly that iwi are a “treaty partner.” She describes Chloe Swarbrick as a “very good friend.”
Dear me.
Yes, she has done some good work in the education portfolio but her socially liberal and woke persona is a major turnoff to that numerically important group of voters, us old buggers.
Remember too she’s also presided over a shambolic immigration policy which has seen 111,000 work visas issued while the number of unemployed New Zealanders has skyrocketed to around 175,000.
The National Party left me when Simon Bridges was rolled as the party was polling 40 percent. Until Covid came along he was on track to lead them to victory in the 2020 election.
It’s been downhill ever since apart from the surge at 2023 election. I had faith in Judith Collins to put some backbone in the outfit but she called off the attack dogs early in the spring of 2020 and never recovered.
The old party of fiscally responsible centre-right voters and traditional family values has become a virtue signaling, free spending and timid political operation, less like a well-oiled machine and more like a battery operated Chinese toy.
If Stanford does succeed Luxon don’t expect any radical departure from the current path of timidity. The only difference is the new Prime Minister will be an attractive married woman in her late 40s who exudes considerably more televisual appeal than her predecessor.
She won’t be addressing matters of race relations and the ever expanding co-governance regimes emerging around the country, and she’s unlikely to make any significant moves to reduce the quantum of government spending and the Public Service.
She started in politics as the electorate agent for that master of political dark arts Murray McCully. She calls him her political mentor. That’s why she hasn’t said a word about wanting the top job and remaining utterly schtum when accosted on her arrival back in Wellington the night before the vote.
She may give the Nats a sugar hit for a few weeks before the election. But she’ll have to defy history to continue as PM after November 7. No Prime Minister installed into the job during a parliamentary term has ever won the subsequent election during my three score years and twelve.
Keith Holyoake in 1957, Jack Marshall in 1972, Mike Moore in 1990, Jenny Shipley in 1999 and Bill English in 2017 were all unable to form government after the subsequent election.
That’s why if Erica Stanford does get the job it’s no guarantee of a polling surge for the Nats.
The other option appears to be Chris Bishop, a man I like for his work ethic and the direction of travel he wants to take New Zealand’s planning and resource management regime. He loves cricket too – in my mind a huge plus although for most, sadly, completely irrelevant.
But sadly I don’t think he has the wide electoral appeal of Mrs Stanford and in this age the concept of women in charge still appeals to large sectors of the electorate. If she wins on Wednesday, it would be like the year 2000 all over again with the country having a woman Prime Minister, Governor-General and Chief Justice.
The removal of Luxon ends one problem for the National Party and the government. I’m yet to be convinced Erica Stanford is the solution.


If Erica Stanford becomes the leader of the National Party, I expect we can kiss goodbye to any further possibility of National supporting the bill to define women and men in legislation, too. Apparently, her daughter dabbled in ‘trans’ a few years ago, which she moved on from eventually, but so many parents whose kids go down that path completely lose all their commonsense about it.
Thanks Peter , interesting points of view.
The National Caucus will have tough decisions to make. Dropping Luxon is not risk free.
I like Bishop but he might have limited appeal. Maybe as deputy PM.
National has a problem attracting woman voters. Maybe Stamford or Willis will resonate with more woman voters. This might offset the losses of those who want National to remain a party for old white blokes.
I'm not sure where Stamford stands on gender. She's probably more in touch with younger voters and females than Luxon ( and you and I). If she opposes the NZF gender legislation that's a red flag for me. But that should really be a conscience vote not Party Policy.
However Stamford's acceptance of gay rights doesn't necessarily extend to supporting trans having the legal rights of a woman ( or man). Women need protected spaces and rights to fairness in sport etc. so I support the NZF gender bill. However the gay community deserves recognition and reasonable rights - like the right to marry and not be discriminated against because of their beliefs.
I'm more concerned about Stamford's attitude to co-governance and Maori affairs. Her record here is mixed and reflects Nationals underperformance in this area. To date she's had limited scope lot show her true feelings . It's an identity crisis National has - politically it appears it still accepts many of the Maoris assertions about their rights under the Treaty. As long as they do this they won't slow down He Puapua.