Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Katrina Biggs's avatar

If Erica Stanford becomes the leader of the National Party, I expect we can kiss goodbye to any further possibility of National supporting the bill to define women and men in legislation, too. Apparently, her daughter dabbled in ‘trans’ a few years ago, which she moved on from eventually, but so many parents whose kids go down that path completely lose all their commonsense about it.

Grant's avatar

Thanks Peter , interesting points of view.

The National Caucus will have tough decisions to make. Dropping Luxon is not risk free.

I like Bishop but he might have limited appeal. Maybe as deputy PM.

National has a problem attracting woman voters. Maybe Stamford or Willis will resonate with more woman voters. This might offset the losses of those who want National to remain a party for old white blokes.

I'm not sure where Stamford stands on gender. She's probably more in touch with younger voters and females than Luxon ( and you and I). If she opposes the NZF gender legislation that's a red flag for me. But that should really be a conscience vote not Party Policy.

However Stamford's acceptance of gay rights doesn't necessarily extend to supporting trans having the legal rights of a woman ( or man). Women need protected spaces and rights to fairness in sport etc. so I support the NZF gender bill. However the gay community deserves recognition and reasonable rights - like the right to marry and not be discriminated against because of their beliefs.

I'm more concerned about Stamford's attitude to co-governance and Maori affairs. Her record here is mixed and reflects Nationals underperformance in this area. To date she's had limited scope lot show her true feelings . It's an identity crisis National has - politically it appears it still accepts many of the Maoris assertions about their rights under the Treaty. As long as they do this they won't slow down He Puapua.

24 more comments...

Ready for more?